What Are Godfrey’s Arguments for Adopting Eppie in “Silas Marner?”

Answer

What are Godfrey’s arguments for adopting Eppie in “Silas Marner?”

“Silas Marner” is the third novel by English author George Eliot (1819-1880), the pen name of Mary Ann Evans. It was published in 1861. In the novel, Godfrey Cass wants to adopt Eppie because he believes it is his duty as her biological father. Godfrey also believes Eppie will have a better life with him and his wife, Nancy. 

Providing Her Better Life: Godfrey Cass argues that he can give Eppie things Silas Marner cannot, like a wealthy home, good clothes, and a higher social status. He believes he can provide her with a better position and everything of the best. He thinks these will make her happy. Godfrey also feels it is his right as her biological father to provide for her. Godfrey says:

It’s my duty, Marner, to own Eppie as my child, and provide for her. She is my own child.

Fixing Past Mistakes: Godfrey sees adopting Eppie as a way to fix his past mistakes. He regrets not claiming her earlier. He wants to adopt Eppie because of his guilt and desire to correct his failure as a father.

However, Godfrey misunderstands the deep bond between Silas and Eppie. He thinks offering her wealth will be enough to convince her. But Eppie values love and family over money. She replies that she won’t leave his father, Silas.

In termination, Godfrey’s arguments are based on material benefits and his right as her biological father. He fails to see that true happiness comes from love and belonging, not wealth or status.